| Position | Name | Club |
|---|---|---|
| F | Phillip Goodrum | Carolina Dynamo |
| F | Luke Brown | Seacoast United Phantoms |
| F | Fernando Robayo | Westchester Flames |
| M | Gabriel Meireles | AC Connecticut |
| M | Ezana Kahsay | Reading United AC |
| M | DeJean Charlton | Evergreen FC |
| M | Deri Corfe | Ocean City Nor'easters |
| D | Mauricio Coimbra | Western Mass Pioneers |
| D | Tennant McVea | Lionsbridge FC |
| D | Patrick Keary | GPS Portland Phoenix |
| GK | William Scott | Tobacco Road FC |