| Position | Name | Club |
|---|---|---|
| F | Kinoshita Ryosuke | Des Moines Menace |
| F | Max Wilschrey | Cincinnati Dutch Lions |
| F | Austin Ricci | Michigan Bucks |
| F | Sullivan Oliveira Silva | Thunder Bay Chill |
| M | Nicolas Clasen | Des Moines Menace |
| M | Eduardo Capote | West Virginia Chaos |
| M | John Leisman | Kaw Valley FC |
| D | Kyle Clinton | Cincinnati Dutch Lions |
| D | Troy Reeves | St. Louis Lions |
| D | Grant Stoneman | Chicago FC United |
| GK | Patrick Irankunda | St. Louis Lions |