| Position | Name | Club |
|---|---|---|
| F | Jacob Shaffelburg | Black Rock FC |
| F | Brian Saramago | New York Red Bulls U23 |
| F | Mayele Malango | Boston Bolts |
| M | Simone Raiola | Ocean City Nor'easters |
| M | Theo Quartey | Black Rock FC |
| M | Alex Moztarzadeh | North Carolina FC U23 |
| M | Romario Hulea | AC Connecticut |
| D | Tremaine Bryan | Westchester Flames |
| D | Sunnattillo Khusanov | FA Euro New York |
| D | Fredlin Mompremier | Ocean City Nor'easters |
| GK | Bennet Strutz | Reading United AC |