| Position | Name | Club |
|---|---|---|
| F | Allen Gavilanes | New York Red Bulls U23 |
| M | Robinson Moshobane | Charlotte Eagles |
| M | Dario Jovanovski | Boston Bolts |
| M | Ilias Kosmidis | Carolina Dynamo |
| M | Miguel Timm | Myrtle Beach Mutiny |
| M | Zach Zandi | Reading United AC |
| D | Zarin Tuten | Lehigh Valley United |
| D | Vandyke Gyau | The Villages SC |
| D | Conner Norten-Baker | Myrtle Beach Mutiny |
| D | Tyler Botte | Long Island Rough Riders |
| GK | Dayne St. Clair | New York Red Bulls U23 |